Search
A warmly lit restaurant table for two beside a window overlooking softly blurred brick buildings on a late-autumn evening.

From October to December, Sheridan's Restaurant Tab Is Mostly Paid by Locals

From October through December 2025, visitors paid for 25% of all restaurant spending in Sheridan County, according to Sheridan County Travel & Tourism's Summer 2026 industry update. That was the smallest visitor share of any quarter SCTT reported. The other three dollars of every four came from people who were not visitors. This post publishes the week before Thanksgiving, which puts us right in the middle of that same stretch for 2026.

The share matters more this year than most. One of downtown's best-known dining owners has put two restaurants up for new ownership, one of those restaurants shows a temporary closure notice, and several small food businesses made their debuts this fall.

The Quarter With the Fewest Visitors at the Table

Here is the visitor share of spending across the four most recent quarters in the report, for restaurants and for retail:

Quarter Visitor share of restaurant spending Visitor share of retail spending
July–September 2025 34% 61%
October–December 2025 25% 77%
January–March 2026 42% 94%
April–June 2026 38% 93%

Two things stand out. First, visitors' share of restaurant spending was higher in January through March 2026 than in either summer quarter on the list. The quarter where restaurants lean most on the home crowd is the one that starts in October.

Second, retail and restaurants split apart in the same quarter. Even in October through December 2025, visitors paid for 77% of retail spending, while their share of restaurant spending fell to a quarter. Downtown shops still lean on out-of-town shoppers in late fall, and restaurants mostly do not. These figures are shares, not dollar totals, so they show who is paying at the table rather than how full the tables are.

For scale, SCTT puts travel spending in Sheridan County at $165.8 million for all of 2025.

What a Small Visitor Share Means for a Small Town's Kitchens

The pressure comes from simple arithmetic. Outside tourist season, a county of about 33,000 people supports more than 100 restaurants, tasting rooms, brew pubs, lounges and bars, as The Sheridan Press reported this fall. Christer Johansson, co-owner of Le Rêve and The Warehouse Gastropub, put it this way in that article:

"We're in a small town in Sheridan, and there are a lot of restaurants for the population that we have. It's difficult to find, in that pool of people, enough people to… make it functional, successful (and) work financially."

Earlier this year, he walked through the math in another Sheridan Press story on local restaurants' revenue. Twenty thousand residents spread across 100 restaurants works out to 200 potential customers per restaurant, and that assumes everyone eats out every day. In the same story, Olha Wasitowski, owner of Olha's Market, described business falling about 50% from summer to winter. She said her market employed 10 people and that she planned to shorten hours in the winter. Olha's is at 1841 S. Sheridan Ave., and its online ordering page currently takes scheduled orders.

The Press listed Hygge Hearth Coffee, Dragon Wall Buffet, Killy's Smokehouse and Gunslinger's Fingers and Gelato among the eateries that had closed over the previous year. It also reported that Range Bar and Grill had closed temporarily. Put those closures next to SCTT's 25% figure, and the fourth quarter starts to look like the stretch that decides which kitchens make it to spring.

The Corner of Main and Alger This Winter

The clearest example sits at Main and East Alger Streets. Christer and Gina Johansson opened The Warehouse Gastropub in 2022 and Le Rêve Restaurant & Raw Bar two years later. This fall, they told The Sheridan Press they were looking for new owners for both. They said what matters most to them is that the next owners "have a fighting chance of being successful and keeping the places open," and they reported several inquiries already.

Le Rêve is in the Historic Cady Building at 1 East Alger Street. It serves dinner Wednesday through Saturday, 4 to 9 p.m., and offers regular live piano music. The Cady building has stood at that corner since 1893 and once housed an opera house and a hotel. The Johanssons bought it in 2020, gutted the interior and reinforced it with steel beams before opening a French-inspired dining room. In 2025, Le Rêve was a James Beard Foundation semifinalist for best new restaurant. With a Wednesday-through-Saturday schedule, a Sunday-to-Tuesday dinner plan downtown will have to go somewhere else. For holiday closures and special hours, the restaurant asks diners to call (307) 306-0505.

Next door, the couple's 15-room boutique hotel is still under construction. The exterior masonry was supposed to start in October 2025 but began in April after a late shipment. Poorly fabricated stone for the front of the building then caused more delays. As of early October, crews were waiting on another piece, landscaping had moved from this fall to next spring, and the interior design was not yet finished. The Johanssons have said they would consider selling the hotel project to the right buyer and otherwise still plan to open it, at whatever pace the work allows.

A few blocks away, at 333 N. Brooks Street, The Warehouse fills a former furniture warehouse that has been part of Sheridan since the 1940s. In April it moved to an upscale menu with steak frites, pesto salmon, elk bolognese and craft cocktails. Its website now opens with the notice "WE ARE TEMPORARILY CLOSED."

Newer Names Arriving in the Same Season

Several small food businesses made their debuts this fall with a ribbon cutting, a pop-up or a new storefront, right as the visitor share of restaurant spending dropped to its low point.

  • The GOAT Creamery & Fizz Co., 24 E. Grinnell Plaza, in the former Platte Hemp Company space. The Sheridan Press reported that it planned to serve scooped ice cream, gelato, dirty sodas, floats and milkshakes. The Sheridan County Chamber of Commerce held a ribbon cutting there on October 20.
  • Saddle and Sugar Donuts, run by Jenni Curtis, Makayla Gonzales and Amber Tyler. According to The Sheridan Press, it started at a September garage sale and now sells rotating doughnut flavors at Saturday pop-ups hosted by Tractor Supply, starting at 8 a.m. The owners have said they hope to find commercial kitchen space.
  • Crazy Woman/The Chocolate Tree, 134 N. Main St. The shop marked its new ownership, name and location with a September 15 ribbon cutting, and it sells chocolate along with gifts, home décor, jewelry and logo clothing.

Just up the block, The Shade Tree Boutique opened October 24 at 117 N. Main St., in the former Bought Beautifully space. It is a clothing and gift shop, which puts it on the retail side of SCTT's table, where visitors still paid 77% of the spending in late 2025. The food businesses that are new this fall face very different math. Whoever comes in through their doors in November and December is mostly local.

Thanksgiving Week to the Christmas Stroll

The calendar for the rest of this quarter is short and busy. Thanksgiving is next Thursday, November 26. The next day, the Christmas Stroll kicks off its four-week button game on Main Street, which brings people downtown through Christmas Eve. Le Rêve's Wednesday-through-Saturday schedule overlaps the first days of Stroll weekend. The GOAT, the Chocolate Tree and the Main Street shops are all within a short walk of the corner of Main and Alger.

After the Stroll comes January through March. In early 2026, visitors' share of restaurant spending climbed back to 42%. The six weeks between now and New Year's are the last stretch of the quarter when visitors paid the smallest share of the restaurant tab.

If family is coming for the holidays and you'd like them close to Main Street dinners and the Stroll, the team at Powder Horn Realty can help you find a place for them through our vacation rentals, six miles from downtown. Give us a call, and we'll gladly suggest which nights to book a table for while they're here.

Live Where You Play

At Powder Horn Realty, Inc., we value our clients and relationships. Our customers rate us as honest, trustworthy, hard-working, dependable and determined, and our goal is to provide you with impeccable service at all times. We will work for you 24/7 to ensure a smooth and successful experience.

Follow Us on Instagram